Saturday, August 08, 2009

Who needs the beach?

A number of friends have told Skyler and me how bewildered they are that we didn't spend time on the beach during our recent stay in Samoa. We immersed our bodies in streams and in a hotel pool, but apparently these experiences don't count as 'real' swims, because they weren't preceded and followed by hours spent lounging on golden sand in the sun, or in the shade of a coconut tree. 'You didn't go to the beach - what did you do over there?' one friend asked us.

There is a widespread belief in New Zealand that the only reason to venture to an island in the South Pacific is to 'escape to the beach'. Nations like Fiji and the Cook Islands have built substantial tourism industries around their many excellent beaches; Samoa, a latecomer to the tourist game, is trying to attract some of the Kiwis and Aussies who used to visit Fiji by distinguishing its shambolic but good-natured democracy from Fiji's military dictatorship.

It remains to be seen whether this marketing strategy will be successful - ethical beach bums may be disappointed by the relative paucity of golden sand on the rocky shores of Upolu and Savai'i islands - but some of the less desirable elements of what economists like to call a 'tourism industry infrastructure' have already fallen into place. The southern outskirts of the Samoan capital Apia, for instance, now feature a series of chic, abominably expensive restaurants with names like Scalinis and Giordanos - places which serve no purpose except to reassure holidaying residents of St Heliers and Ponsonby that they are not, in fact, holidaying in the Third World. After a hard day sunbathing, there's nothing like a stylish Italian meal concocted by an imported chef. Ostentatiously exclusive beach resorts have appeared on the northwestern coast of Upolu, close to the airport, and on the eastern coast of Savai'i.

It's true that the islands of the Pacific have some very desirable beaches, but so does France, and nobody who visits that country and neglects to lie in the sun on the Riviera coast is regarded as an oddball when he returns from his holiday. Why do Kiwi travellers like to learn about the histories and cultures of European nations, but not about the histories and cultures of Pacific nations? Why do we insist on reducing societies like Samoa and Fiji to a collection of beaches adorned with picturesque natives?

It seems to me that New Zealanders have still not shaken off the idea that societies like Samoa are essentially non-historical. When we think about the history of a European nation like France or Britain, we think of a succession of eras, and the development and modification of cultures; when we think about the past of a society like Samoa or Fiji, we think of a single, essential culture which contact with the 'outside' world can only serve to corrode. We will therefore consent to view the performance of a 'traditional' dance and song - often a confection of cliches dreamed up by a papalagi resort owner - as we relax with martinis after a day on the beach, but we flinch from learning about the modern history and contemporary cultures of the island on which we are holidaying.

The narrow focus of the Pacific tourism industry has at least two significant effects. In small, tourism-dependant states like Fiji, it leads to wildly uneven development, as regions blessed with pleasant beaches and proximity to international airports - the zone between Nadi and Suva on the main Fijian island of Viti Levu, for instance - attract the lion's share of investment in roads and other infrastructure, and less desirable regions miss out.

In New Zealand and, I suspect, Australia, the obsession with lying on beaches means that people can visit nations like Fiji again and again without gaining any sort of understanding about the history and social dynamics of the places. I remember going to a dinner which turned into an argument about Fiji, and about the military government of Frank Banimarama. One of the dinner guests slammed Bainimarama as an anti-Indian racist, and said that he should be 'wiped out', along with Sitiveni Rabuka, George Speight and others involved in earlier Fijian coups. Another guest strong disagreed with this, and claimed that the indigenous people of Fiji needed their rights protected by a special form of government, because they were still struggling to adjust to the changes contact with the West had brought.

The other dinner guests lined up with one or another of the two people who had started to argue, but what no one seemed to realise is that Frank Bainimarama has nothing at all to do with Fijian chauvinists like Rabuka and Speight, and that he has justified his coup and his government by presenting himself as the defender of the rights of Fiji's Indian minority. All of the people sitting around the table had been to Fiji, and many of them had visited the country since Bainimarama's coup, yet none had the most basic understanding of the political situation there. They had all spent their time in Fiji lying on the beach.

I'm not sure whether either my mocking friends or the tourism operators will notice, but I'm going to sketch out three possible alternatives to a beach-bound holiday on Samoa in a series of posts to this blog over the next few days. There are certainly other tours which could be devised - the ones I'll be offering reflect my particular enthusiasms, rather than the limitations of Samoa.

Let's begin with the Samoan Freedom Struggle Tour


At the beginning of the twentieth century Samoa was divided between Germany and America. The Germans got the two largest islands, Upolu and Savai'i, while the Americans took the small eastern island of Tutuila, which has an excellent harbour. In 1914 New Zealand troops arrived in Apia, and seized control of Germany's colony on behalf of the British Empire and the Allied powers which were confronting the Kaiser on the battlefields of Europe. The German administration of Samoa had been conducted by paternalistic but relatively competent intellectuals: New Zealand preferred to hand the job of governing the islands over to a succession of deeply racist and utterly incompetent military men, small town mayors, and high country sheep farmers.

Samoan opposition to New Zealand rule hardened after Kiwi bureaucrats allowed a boat carrying the Spanish flu into the colony in 1918, and then stood by and watched, refusing offers of medical assistance from America, as the disease killed 22% of the inhabitants of Upolu and Savai'i. New Zealand attempts to 'beautify' and 'rationalise' villages by tearing up hibiscus hedges and trees and placing fale in tidy rows further angered Samoans. By the mid-1920s, an opposition movement called 'the Mau' had coalesced around a young and handsome nobleman called Tamasese and a wealthy, stupendously fat half-caste trader named Olaf Nelson. Samoans refused to pay taxes to the New Zealand authorities and refused to work in plantations, bringing the economy to a standstill. They established an alternative government and an alternative police force, and held regular protest processions. The colonial authorities exiled and jailed Mau leaders, but they could neither break the movement nor provoke it to violence.

At the end of 1929, in a display of frustration and panic, New Zealand police aimed a machine gun into a Mau demonstration in central Apia, killing Tamasese and eight others. In the aftermath of this massacre Mau activists fled Apia and hid in the deep valleys and mountainous forests of Upolu; a force of marines was despatched from New Zealand on the HMS Dunedin to hunt for them. The New Zealand forces marched backwards and forwards across Upolu, raiding villages, smashing up fale, and taking women and elderly men away for questioning. A few low-level activists were captured, and a small boy was shot in the back and killed, but the leaders of the Mau remained elusive, even when a Tiger Moth biplane flew over Upolu trying to spot them in the forest. In New Zealand, criticism of the repression of the Mau movement grew, with Labour Party leader Harry Holland asking angry questions in parliament.

As the sick bay of the HMS Dunedin filled up with men felled by malaria and dengue fever, a fresh detachment of troops began to train at a base in Paraparaumu in preparation for deployment to the troublesome colony. Lacking any alternative, the Ward government intended to use a civilian vessel to transport the men to Apia, but this plans was foiled when the Seaman's Union announced that its members would refuse to work any such ship. Partly because of the union's stand, the reinforcements from Paraparaumu never made it to Samoa. In 1935 Labour came to power in New Zealand, anti-Mau laws were scrapped, and Olaf Nelson was allowed to return from exile. In 1962, Samoa finally became independent.

A Few Directions

On your way from the airport to Apia, stop at the village of Lepea, which was the home of Olaf Nelson and a major centre of the Mau movement. In the middle of the village, on the left hand side of the road, you'll see a large monument to Tamasese, who was brought, dying, to Lepea after being machine gunned by the police on the date Samoans remember as 'Black Saturday'. Tamasese died surrounded by his family and supporters, and his last words are recorded on the monument. Their English translation is:

My blood has been spilt for Samoa. I am proud to give it. Do not dream of avenging it, as it was spilt in peace. If I die, peace must be maintained at any price.

Look across the road and you'll see the old centre of Lepea, which was subjected to one of the New Zealand authorities' 'beautification' campaigns in the early 1920s. The straight rows of fales, lack of gardens and trees, and 'English village green' all reflect the obsession of the imperialists with Anglicising the Samoan way of life.

Carry on down the road, to the next village of Vaimoso, which is nowadays a suburb of Apia. Vaimoso was the place where Tamasese was living in 1924, when he refused an order to destroy a hibiscus hedge near his house. This event marked the beginning of his confrontation with Samoa's rulers. On the left hand side of the road in the middle of Vaimoso you can see the remains of the bandstand which was the centre of the alternative government the Mau established in the late '20s. This was the place where villages brought supplies of food and unofficial 'tax' payments, in defiance of the New Zealand authorities; it was also the locus of the large unofficial police force which the Mau established as an alternative to New Zealand law. Most of the bandstand was destroyed by a cyclone in 2004, but the numerous hibiscus hedges that grow around Vaimoso are more durable memorials to the spirit of the Mau.

When you make it to the centre of Apia, drive down Beach Road until you reach the old police station, where New Zealanders fired their machine gun at a massive Mau demonstration on Saturday, December the 28th, 1929. Tamasese was hit after he rushed to the front of the demonstration and shouted at the police to stop the shooting. Further down Beach Road, just past Aggie Grey's hotel, is the bridge over the Vaisigano Stream, where demonstrators massed before the fateful rally.

Take a drive through Upolu's interior to Safata Bay on the south coast of the island, where New Zealand forces sometimes based themselves during the hunt for the Mau. From the isolated villages around the bay, police and marines slogged into the jungle-covered mountains where the Mau hid.

Take a ferry to Savai'i, and on the way you'll notice Apolima, the tip of an ancient volcano that sits in the strait between Samoa's two main islands, surrounded by strong currents. The Mau leaders Faumauina and Afamasaga and were banished here in 1927. They quickly converted all of the island's one hundred residents to the Mau.

Faumauina is an interesting character: as a young man, he was a supporter of New Zealand, and he was even picked to be the leader of the Fetu (the word means 'Star'), a paramilitary youth group which was established to offer support to the colonial authorities and to spread 'civilised, British' values amongst Samoans. Later, though, he turned against the colonists, to the extent that he became the leader of the Mau after the killing of Tamasese.

Drive around Savai'i to the village of Asau, at the northwestern edge of the island. This is the place where Tamasese was banished, after he refused orders to destroy his hibiscus hedge in 1924. In traditional Samoan society, banishment from one's village was the worst punishment short of death, but it could only be imposed after proper deliberations by a village fono (council). New Zealand administrators infuriated Samoans when they appropriated the punishment, and began to inflict it arbitrarily on noblemen like Tamasese. After Tamasese returned from Savai'i, piloting an outrigger canoe, he was sent to Mt Eden Prison in Auckland.

When you get back to Apia, drive out on the Mulinuu peninsula, at the western end of the city's harbour, and take a look at Samoa's parliament, as well as the Pulenuu fale, which is the building where MPs meet members of village fono to negotiate the coordination of central and village government. The highly decentralised nature of Samoan government, and the continued administration of swathes of land by fono, are reflections of the ideology of the Mau movement, which insisted that 'fa'a Samoa' - the 'Samoan way' - offered a framework for national development superior to the 'modernisation' programmes drawn up by New Zealand colonists.

My sources for this potted history are Michael J Field's Mau: Samoa's Struggle for Freedom (Polynesian Press, 1991) and Malama Meleisa's The Making of Modern Samoa (University of the South Pacific, 1987). Both books are well worth reading, even if you're not contemplating a trip to Samoa.

You might, of course, come across the odd nice beach during your travels to these sites associated with the Samoan independence struggle...


Anonymous Anonymous said...

Marvellous. Interesting that in many ways that colonial myth of the Pacific is today willingly perpetuated by locals. That romanticised image of sun, sand and authentically exotic but unthreatening locals is certainly the basis of the whole South Pacific brand. It’s kind of a conspiracy in which island locals willingly collude in, particularly in places like the Cook Islands where small-scale, locally-owned honeymoon venues are organised around encouraging newly-weds to project all their own dewy-eyed feelings of warmth and romance onto the landscape/beachscape/local inhabitants, and then see it reflected back at them.

Lots of people have shown how tourism has maintained relations of dependency and led to unequal development. Not so much has been said about how islands – even ones with really foreign dominated industries like Vanuatu and Fiji – have been able to manipulate international tourism to sustain traditional ways of living. This has been particularly so in Samoa, but weakening somewhat now as the ADB has its claws in tourism development policy (along with everything else).

Oh, and I hear Beach-fale are a pretty good way to enjoy the beach while avoiding those imported Italian restaurants!

9:24 pm  
Anonymous Matt R said...

Marvellous. Interesting that in many ways that colonial myth of the Pacific is today willingly perpetuated by locals. That romanticised image of sun, sand and authentically exotic but unthreatening locals is certainly the basis of the whole South Pacific brand. It’s kind of a conspiracy in which island locals willingly collude in, particularly in places like the Cook Islands where small-scale, locally-owned honeymoon venues are organised around encouraging newly-weds to project all their own dewy-eyed feelings of warmth and romance onto the landscape/beachscape/local inhabitants, and then see it reflected back at them.

Lots of people have shown how tourism has maintained relations of dependency and led to unequal development. Not so much has been said about how islands – even ones with really foreign dominated industries like Vanuatu and Fiji – have been able to manipulate international tourism to sustain traditional ways of living. This has been particularly so in Samoa, but weakening somewhat now as the ADB has its claws in tourism development policy (along with everything else).

Oh, and I hear Beach-fale are a pretty good way to enjoy the beach while avoiding those imported Italian restaurants!

9:25 pm  
Blogger Richard Taylor said...

I agree with anonymous - I went to Fiji in 1973 - my experience was a bit different as we saw the "beautiful" side of Fiji but I also had read of aspects of Colonialism and exploitation etc; and we stayed at the University of Suva (we knew someone so it was free). And we were able to get to know some of the locals thus...)

Certainly on an Island we visited (Ovalau) we saw some beautiful scenery and fish etc but one knew thee was lot more to it than that - I have to admit that I was so hot when we went that most of the time we didn't do much at all let alone visit politically significant places but I noticed the poverty (around Suva) and so on. I also noticed a tension between native Fijians and Indians - some of whom were Muslim. Tension - not antagonism. However mainly it was just very very hot and beaches etc bored me* so I was glad to get home. But the country of central Fiji is quite beautiful and very interesting - mountains - with mongoose flashing across the roads etc

* Although I recall seeing a manta ray and also the sea life on the coral reefs on Ovalau were beautiful, and it was fascinating to see so many crabs scuttling along ethe beaches...

9:54 pm  
Blogger Richard Taylor said...

And in those days Ponsonby, where I lived, was populated by mainly poor Polynesian people (and others of the "working class").

I learnt Samoan and some Maori there in the 70s. I was quite fluent in Samoan at one stage (one of the few languages I learnt very well) - I can still can pronounce it quite well...I used to speak to Samoan workers in factories quite well.

Ponsonby was considered a slum in those days (many people felt the houses perhaps should be demolished and it may have been a good idea (the housing conditions were in many cases atrocious) except that the land prices rose so much); and no one (or few of us) would have dreamed or desired that it would become what it is prices rose as it slowly became a white area and Polynesians were pushed into Otara etc.

N.Z. has a huge Polynesian population but few white New Zealanders bother to learn about their culture or history - as with Maori and others here.

So again this is a good post Maps - enlightening and informative indeed.

10:09 pm  
Anonymous John B. said...

A fascinating account. Thank you for this.

9:58 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

People who lie on the beach all day are like prawns sitting on the barbie waiting for a fork to go up their arses and turn them over.

11:00 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear friend,

please read this. ALL of our lives could depend on it.


The nearer consequences are even more terrifying, my friend:
a) most foreign powers we are dealing with have researched Obama (thing of China and their Indonesian connections, or Russia), and probably have proof of him being an imposter, fact which makes him an easy prey to blackmail;

b) all treaties signed by Obama are susceptible for reconsideration, all other parties drawing blood from the US as they will see fit, bringing upon this country only misery, from scorn and ridicule to disadvantage, large (think billions) expenses, to loss of influence and jeopardising our military personnel abroad.

c) As far as locally, leaving aside the political costs, consider the fact that Obama is also CRIMINALLY LIABLE for charlatanie and swindling, because he rised more $700 millions in electoral funds from unsuspecting citizens UNDER FALSE PRETENSE, KNOWING THAT HE MAY NOT, LEGALLY, BE A UNITED STATES PRESIDENT.
I particularly love this last one, and I am looking forward to hear about the first Obama donor (debit card carriers included) suing him for false representation and asking for reparations – this can be the tidal wave overturning the YESWECAN boat, the DebitCard Revolt asking for proof that he hasn’t tricked them intoo spending their dollars.

A mess, a horrible mess generated by a narcissistic adventurer who cynically took advantage of the circumstances generated by an economic crisis & a cultural implosion. Yes, we can – this affair will have an ugly, ugly denuement, and MANE, TEKEL, FARES creeps on the wall…

Jul 26, 2009 - 9:06 am

4:46 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Your a dick.

11:42 am  
Blogger maps said...

Thanks John B - and by the way your blog looks fascinating. I remember reading about a slim but fine book about the Biafra war as a boy and being moved.

Matt: I agree that Samoans work with Australasian cliches about island paradises. I alo think that their attitude to living and working abroad is very canny. I know it sounds silly, but I had the thought that the whole of Samoa was like one of those 70s communes whose members took turns leaving their rural paradise and working in the ugly city, in order to keep the enterprise going.

Richard: do you remember which one of the small Marxist groups published a paper partly in Samoan in the '70s? I think it was a split from the CPNZ. Obviously Samoan was an important language of the union movement. It was interesting to read McCarten saying that Philip Field was, or appeared to be, an atheist and a Marxist in the '80s...

2:24 pm  
Anonymous Lots in Samara Costa Rica said...

Hello I want to congratulate to them by its site of the Web of the excellent looks like entertained and very good very to me it elaborated. I invite them to that they explore a little on my Web site.

5:40 am  
Anonymous Green Parks said...

Hello.. Firstly I would like to send greetings to all readers. After this, I recognize the content so interesting about this article. For me personally I liked all the information. I would like to know of cases like this more often. In my personal experience I might mention a book called Firesales Costa Rica in this book that I mentioned have very interesting topics, and also you have much to do with the main theme of this article.

8:45 am  
Anonymous Florida Beach Cottages said...

Very well-detailed although I would have to agree with the people who said that the beach is where the "real" swimming is if the beach is that near to you.

4:28 am  
Anonymous Online High School Diploma said...

It's good to see this information in your post,

8:30 pm  
Anonymous aanrechtblad graniet said...

I m saving your blog in my personal folder to visit again You made legal points within this article that I sense need further examination. I agree with most all of this info. amazing work.

7:50 pm  
Blogger tasnuva lotika said...

Attract your readers’ interest with AN intriguing headline. you have got simply many seconds to capture the audience’s power of write my essay for me. Don’t allow them to quit learning, before they discover out however glorious your papers is. tempt them with a desirable, however correct, headline.

12:33 pm  
Blogger justin adams said...

When learning an overseas language, one in every of the foremost troublesome things to possess to try to to is write a paper here best essay writing services. Whether or not you're simply setting out to learn the language otherwise you have studied it for several years the task actually has its challenges. Fortuitously there square measure some superb resources on the net that may assist you get into any scenario.

2:49 am  
Anonymous website laten maken said...

It seems like an educational blog which always some new information to visitors and Enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.

6:00 am  
Anonymous Pre Marriage Courses said...

Excellent information on your blog, thank you for taking the time to share with us.

11:10 pm  
Blogger doglas markel said...

Do not danger every the time strive you've place into get a doctorate by decide the wrong thesis raise repair for assist. Below are one or two of the way that have established very dependable at intervals the history.

8:56 pm  
Blogger fitria maharani said...

Thanks a lot for sharing. Will check back later for more of your articles.

3:23 am  
Blogger fitria maharani said...

It does, huh? Thank you!

3:23 am  
Blogger fitria maharani said...

thanks your share information

3:24 am  
Anonymous best essay writing services said...

It is much more interesting to read an article if it contains pictures. Thanks for this information.
cheap essay writing service

12:03 am  
Anonymous canadian essay writing service said...

Amazing blog :)Thanks :)
custom essay writing

12:08 am  
Anonymous best essay writing services said...

Pictures are really great and this post is very interesting :)
P.S.canadian essay writing services

11:27 pm  
Blogger Azam Zami said...

This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works.
harga tas wanita

9:02 pm  
Blogger get rid of cellulite said...

I was looking for something like this…I found it quiet interesting, hopefully you will keep posting such blogs….Keep sharing.
stenen keukenwerkblad

10:14 pm  
Anonymous Accredited GED Online said...

Impressive work. Lots of good info. Thanks.

10:50 pm  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home